It’s an easy temptation when you’re just starting your blog. You want to get your content in as many places as possible. So you go to sharethis, like the look of all the buttons and decide to add them all onto your site, hoping that this will bring you much-needed traffic at the start. The chances are, it won’t.
There are now so many options for sharing content, it can be easy to get lost in the mess. You also have to ask yourself the value of sharing your content. Is it going to be in the right places, where you’ll attract a relevant audience? I see far more value in engaging with someone on my blog, encouraging them to comment on a post, than I do in 50 diggs. It means they have a deeper level of engagement. It’s very easy to distract people with all the fancy ’sharing’ options, when you actually want them to do is read the content you’ve spent time producing.
You have to also question the value of sharing. Is it actually going to bring new traffic to your site, or are you sending people on a meandering path to submit your content everywhere, when actually, it’s not really reaching new audiences? Obviously sharing content is valuable, but I don’t want people to get distracted into spending all their time on making something shareable across multiple platforms, when there may be negligible benefit to this. On our blog, we have a retweet button on posts because we’ve recognised that it’s where a lot of our traffic comes from and it’s a relevant audience for our type of content. Honestly, I think that’s enough. Anymore and you begin to confuse people – when is it right to digg, stumbelupon, tweet, delicious, like ? Too many options and the point is lost.
Google reader for example have started to confuse me with all the features they’ve added. It’s great that I can share a post, I regularly do this and make sure I read other people’s as well. But then I also get options to add a star, to ‘like’ it, to share it with a note, to send it to friendfeed. I admit I get a bit lost, so I just stick to one option – sharing. Everything else just creates unnecessary noise and dilutes the purpose.
Now I’m not suggesting that you don’t make content that’s shareable, it’s great if it’s going to bring you in front of a new audience. But the way to create shareable content is to write something original, compelling, something that makes you stand out. Something that people actually see a value in and are happy to say that this is something worth reading. A digg button won’t do this for you.
Yeah completely don’t get the share phenomonen. Way too many options. It’s great to be able to allow your readers to option to share your content but what benefit does it have sharing your work on a really small community network, none in my mind.
On my site I allow users to share my content on 5 different social networks. They’re what I deem as the big 5 ones but if my readers want to share on other sites then that’s great but I don’t see the benefit in providing all if those options.
Hi Ben, I agree. I think if people really want to submit something to Digg etc.. then they’re probably going to do it anyway, regardless of whether you have the buttons or not. I think that just too much emphasis on sharing becomes confusing and slightly pointless.
Good info. It can be very tempting just to share and hope for the best, but I think that this laziness really comes across to the reader.
Good post and some interesting points raised.
I suppose it’s the right balance. As you say have someone comment on my site means a lot more to me, that someone has taken the time to think and write something in reply.
Share buttons are a good idea though as you said comments mean more than 50 Diggs or re-tweets, but those RT or Diggs could bring you a few more loyal readers who do contribute.
What do you think?
It’s definitely helpful if it’s going to get you in front of new audiences, but I think the problem comes if it’s the same people sharing across all these sites, then users will just get bombarded with the same content over and over again. It’s a fine line and I can see the benefit in it helping you to get in front of new eyeballs but I’d prefer the engagement primarily to be with the content overall.
Clever post. It is very hard to quantify the value of sharing, although anicdotally there are some good examples. Sharing is a big positive to result from the increasing mass asoption of social media, but like anything in life, getting the balance right is paramount.
[...] I said earlier in the post and as Lauren wrote a couple of days ago you shouldn’t really be worrying to much about all the fancy widgets and services that are [...]